In April 2025, U.S. Senator Dick Durbin, Illinois’ entrenched Democratic powerbroker, finally announced his exit from the Senate after clinging to power for nearly three decades. His decision to retire at 80, revealed on April 23, 2025, has unleashed a chaotic free-for-all among Illinois Democrats, who are now clawing over each other to claim his seat in a state they’ve long taken for granted. The 2026 Senate election, with a primary on March 17 and a general election on November 3, promises to expose the fractures within a Democratic Party desperate to maintain its grip on Illinois amid a resurgent Republican challenge. This article delves into the overcrowded field of Democratic hopefuls, sparse polling data, and the contentious issues fueling a race that could embarrass Durbin’s tarnished legacy.
A Tarnished Legacy
Durbin’s tenure, marked by his iron-fisted control as Senate Democratic Whip since 2005 and his perch atop the Judiciary Committee, is less a story of triumph than one of partisan overreach. His much-touted DREAM Act and DACA program, while championed by progressives, remain mired in controversy, criticized by conservatives as rewarding illegal immigration. His role in confirming 235 federal judges, including Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, is seen by detractors as stacking the judiciary with liberal activists. Durbin’s exit leaves a void not just in his Senate seat but in the Democratic machine he helped build, which now risks crumbling under the weight of its own divisions. Illinois, a Democratic stronghold where Vice President Kamala Harris eked out an 11-point win in 2024, is rated “Solid Democrat” by the Cook Political Report, but the party’s infighting could give Republicans a rare opening.
The Democratic Primary: A Fractured Free-for-All
Durbin’s retirement has triggered a desperate scramble among Illinois Democrats, with over a dozen candidates circling a primary that’s already shaping up to be a brutal, divisive slugfest. The party’s inability to coalesce around a single candidate underscores its lack of discipline and foreshadows a potential debacle. Here’s a look at the key players in this messy contest.
Confirmed Candidates
-
Lieutenant Governor Juliana Stratton: The first to jump in, Stratton declared her candidacy on April 24, 2025, propped up by Governor J.B. Pritzker’s political machine. Her campaign leans heavily on tired progressive talking points—reproductive rights, healthcare, infrastructure—recycling Durbin’s playbook without fresh ideas. Stratton’s early entry and Pritzker’s backing give her a head start, but her reliance on establishment support could alienate voters fed up with Illinois’ Democratic elite.
Potential Candidates
-
U.S. Representative Raja Krishnamoorthi: Sitting on a $19 million war chest, Krishnamoorthi is poised to throw his hat in, but his moderate posturing and tech-heavy focus feel out of touch with Illinois’ working-class struggles. His potential run risks vacating a safe House seat, a reckless move that could cost Democrats down the line.
-
U.S. Representative Lauren Underwood: A 38-year-old House leadership member, Underwood’s healthcare obsession and progressive credentials might excite the base, but her youth and limited statewide profile could leave her outmaneuvered in a crowded field. Her indecision about running only adds to the party’s chaos.
-
U.S. Representative Robin Kelly: Kelly, from the 2nd District, is a long-shot whose gun violence rhetoric might resonate in Chicago but lacks the statewide clout to compete. Her candidacy would likely be a footnote in this overcrowded race.
-
Illinois Treasurer Michael Frerichs: A lesser-known statewide official, Frerichs is rumored to be considering a run, but his bland financial focus and downstate base won’t cut through the noise of flashier contenders.
-
Former Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel: The polarizing ex-mayor and current U.S. Ambassador to Japan is a wildcard whose baggage—botched handling of Chicago’s crime and school closures—could sink any Senate bid. His rumored interest in a 2028 presidential run or the governorship suggests he’s more opportunist than serious contender.
-
Other Congressional Contenders: A laundry list of House Democrats—Bill Foster, Chuy García, Jonathan Jackson, Mike Quigley, Delia Ramirez, Jan Schakowsky, Brad Schneider, Eric Sorensen—are reportedly eyeing the race, with Schakowsky’s recent House retirement fueling speculation. Their collective indecision only deepens the party’s disarray.
-
State-Level Figures: Attorney General Kwame Raoul and vague mentions of state legislators round out a field that’s more cluttered than cohesive, with no clear leader emerging.
Republican Contenders Republicans, sensing weakness in the Democratic meltdown, are gearing up to challenge for a seat they haven’t won since Mark Kirk’s fluke victory in 2010. Durbin’s consistent routs of GOP opponents highlight Illinois’ blue wall, but President Donald Trump’s stronger 2024 showing—narrowing margins in Cook County and Chicago—gives the party hope. Potential candidates include:
-
U.S. Representative Darin LaHood: A leading Republican from the 16th District, LaHood’s sharp rebuke of Durbin’s “out-of-touch liberal policies” signals his interest. His conservative platform and downstate roots could rally rural voters, though cracking Chicago and its suburbs remains a tall order.
-
Other Potential Republicans: Names like former state representative Tom Demmer, disgraced ex-Governor Rod Blagojevich, former House Minority Leader Jim Durkin, and Representatives Mike Bost and Mary Miller have surfaced, but none have committed. Former congressman Rodney Davis is another possibility, though the GOP’s bench looks thin against Illinois’ Democratic machine.
Early Polling Data
Polling for the 2026 race is scarce, reflecting the primary’s distance and the Democrats’ disorganization. A single hypothetical survey by 314 Action, conducted March 24–27, 2025, before Durbin’s announcement, polled 773 likely Democratic primary voters and revealed a tight, uninspiring race:
-
Lauren Underwood: 33%
-
Raja Krishnamoorthi: 30%
-
Juliana Stratton: 16%
-
Robin Kelly: 10%
-
Undecided: 10%
Underwood and Krishnamoorthi’s near-tie shows no candidate has captured voters’ imagination, while Stratton’s weak showing—despite Pritzker’s muscle—suggests her campaign lacks traction. The poll’s pre-retirement timing limits its relevance, but it highlights a fractured field where no one has a clear edge. No general election polls exist, though Illinois’ Democratic tilt favors the eventual nominee—unless the primary leaves them battered and vulnerable to a GOP upset.
Issues Fueling the Mess
The 2026 Illinois Senate race is a microcosm of Democratic dysfunction, amplified by Durbin’s polarizing legacy and the national backlash against a second Trump presidency. Key issues include:
-
Immigration and DACA’s Divisiveness Durbin’s DREAM Act and DACA, hailed by liberals, are lightning rods for criticism, seen by opponents as soft on border security. With Trump’s administration poised to crack down on immigration, Democratic candidates like Stratton and Krishnamoorthi will be forced to defend Durbin’s policies, risking alienation of moderate voters in Chicago’s suburbs and downstate.
-
Healthcare and Abortion Overreach Democrats’ fixation on healthcare and reproductive rights, pushed by Underwood and Stratton, may rally progressives but feels repetitive in a state already aligned with their views. Stratton’s 2022 Senate testimony on Dobbs could be seen as pandering to the base rather than addressing broader economic concerns, a misstep in a volatile midterm climate.
-
Economic Stagnation and Infrastructure Failures Illinois’ economy, plagued by slow job growth and crumbling infrastructure, exposes Durbin’s mixed record on delivering for the state. Krishnamoorthi’s tech-heavy rhetoric and Frerichs’ financial focus feel disconnected from voters struggling with rising costs. Democrats risk losing ground in collar counties, where Durbin’s 560,000-vote margin in 2020 is no longer guaranteed.
-
Gun Violence and Public Safety Failures Chicago’s persistent gun violence, a stain on Democratic governance, will haunt candidates like Kelly, whose advocacy hasn’t translated to results. Balancing progressive calls for reform with demands for tougher policing will be a tightrope, especially in areas where Trump gained in 2024, like Cook and DuPage counties.
-
Judiciary and Partisan Gridlock Durbin’s judicial legacy, including his role in confirming liberal judges, is a flashpoint for conservatives who view it as politicizing the courts. His successor will face pressure to continue this fight, but candidates like Raoul or Stratton risk being painted as extensions of a divisive Democratic establishment.
-
Trump’s Shadow and Midterm Backlash The 2026 midterms, under a Republican Senate (53-47) and Trump’s presidency, historically favor the opposition. Democrats’ hopes of capitalizing on anti-Trump sentiment could backfire if their primary devolves into a circular firing squad, giving Republicans like LaHood a chance to exploit voter frustration with Illinois’ Democratic stranglehold.
Strategic Pitfalls
Democratic Disarray The Democratic primary is a recipe for disaster:
-
Fundraising Frenzy: Krishnamoorthi’s $19 million gives him an edge, but Stratton’s reliance on Pritzker’s donor network could spark a money war. Underwood’s national ties may draw funds, but the sheer number of candidates risks splitting resources and attention.
-
Geographic Fractures: Chicago and its suburbs, Durbin’s 2020 stronghold, are up for grabs, but Stratton and Kelly’s urban focus may clash with Underwood and Krishnamoorthi’s suburban appeal. Downstate, where Frerichs and LaHood have ties, could expose Democratic weaknesses.
-
Party Implosion: Pritzker’s push to clear the field for Stratton has failed, and the growing list of candidates threatens to fracture the party along progressive-moderate lines, weakening the nominee.
Republican Opening Republicans face a steep climb in blue Illinois, but Democratic chaos and Trump’s 2024 gains offer a glimmer of hope. LaHood’s conservatism could energize rural voters, but he’ll need to chip away at Democratic dominance in Chicago and its suburbs—a daunting task against a likely well-funded nominee.
National Fallout Illinois is one of 35 Senate races in 2026, with Democrats defending 13 seats to Republicans’ 22. While Illinois won’t flip easily, a Democratic debacle here could embolden GOP efforts in battlegrounds like Maine or North Carolina. Durbin’s whip role, now up for grabs, adds another layer of turmoil as Senators like Brian Schatz and Amy Klobuchar vie for influence.
Conclusion
The race to replace Dick Durbin is a grim spectacle of Democratic dysfunction, with a bloated primary field—led by Juliana Stratton, Raja Krishnamoorthi, and Lauren Underwood—poised to tear the party apart. Early polling shows a race with no clear leader, reflecting voter apathy and a lack of vision. Issues like immigration, gun violence, and economic stagnation highlight Durbin’s failures and the Democrats’ inability to move beyond his shadow. Republicans, led by Darin LaHood, face long odds but could exploit a divided Democratic electorate. As Illinois stumbles toward 2026, the race risks becoming a case study in how a dominant party can squander its advantage, leaving Durbin’s legacy as a cautionary tale of overreach and division.
Help American Liberty PAC in our mission to elect conservatives and save our nation. Support – American Liberty PAC