Appeals Court Rules Pelosi’s Proxy Voting Unconstitutional in $1.7 Trillion Spending Bill Case

The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 on Friday that the House’s pandemic-era proxy voting rule, put in place under Speaker Nancy Pelosi, violated the Constitution’s Quorum Clause when the House passed the $1.7 trillion omnibus spending bill in December 2022.

“Members of Congress must be present for quorum purposes,” Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority. “‘Proxy presence’ does not count.” He added that “the Quorum Clause’s constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat.”

The case, Texas v. Blanche, was brought by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. The ruling upholds an injunction that bars the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, one provision of the omnibus, against Texas as an employer. It does not strike down the spending law nationwide.

How the bill passed

The House passed the fiscal 2023 spending bill 225-201 days before Christmas 2022. According to Conservative Daily News and Liberty Unyielding, 226 members voted by proxy under the rule Pelosi helped put in place in May 2020 as a COVID emergency measure. The Capitalism Institute reported that some members cast proxy votes while attending a space launch in Florida or a conservative convention. The Senate never adopted proxy voting, and House Republicans ended the practice after winning the majority in the 2022 elections.

A three-judge Fifth Circuit panel had earlier found the proxy rule within the House’s authority. The full court vacated that decision.

The majority and the dissent

Wilson was joined by Chief Judge Elrod and Judges Jones, Smith, Willett, Ho, Duncan, Engelhardt and Oldham, according to an analysis by law professor Jonathan Adler at Reason’s Volokh Conspiracy.

Judge James Graves, joined by six colleagues, dissented. “I cannot agree with their addition of a new requirement to the Quorum Clause,” he wrote. Graves called the majority’s reasoning “illogical, inexplicable, and invalid,” and asked why the remedy “should be limited only to one small sliver of the multitrillion dollar bill.” Judge Haynes dissented separately.

Adler wrote that he doubts the decision will stand and questioned whether courts can rule on the Quorum Clause at all. He also noted that the court’s reasoning could reach other parts of the omnibus. Conservative Daily News, citing Bloomberg Law, reported that the ruling is certain to be appealed to the Supreme Court.

The bottom line

The Constitution says a majority of each house “shall constitute a Quorum to do Business.” For more than two centuries that meant members had to show up. In 2020 House Democrats decided that one member could stand in for others, and two years later they used that rule to pass a $1.7 trillion bill with more than half the chamber voting from somewhere else.

Nine judges held that the Constitution’s text means what it says. Judge Graves himself asked why the remedy should cover only one provision, and Adler noted the reasoning could reach the rest of the omnibus. Every member who let a colleague vote for them on a bill that size should have to explain why they could not be in the chamber.

The Supreme Court should take the case and affirm. The House should also write the lesson into its permanent rules, so that no future majority can bring back proxy voting by a simple rules change.

Help American Liberty PAC in our mission to elect conservatives and save our nation. Support – American Liberty PAC