On August 8, 2022, federal agents searched Mar-a-Lago. They took boxes of documents, including classified material. The search warrant was obtained while Joe Biden was president and Merrick Garland ran the Justice Department. Jack Smith was not yet special counsel; that appointment came months later, in November 2022. Smith later brought the classified-documents indictment. In July 2024 a federal judge in Florida dismissed that case on the ground that Smith’s appointment violated the Constitution. The charges against Donald Trump were never tried. After he returned to office the remaining efforts against him were dropped under the long-standing rule that a sitting president is not prosecuted.
What the Agents Wrote Before the Search
Internal emails from the FBI’s Washington Field Office, declassified and released in December 2025, show that agents told Justice Department lawyers they did not believe they had probable cause for a broad search of the residence, office, and storage areas. One message stated that the field office had articulated that it lacked probable cause and that the department still wanted a wide warrant. The agents preferred other ways to recover the records if possible. The search went ahead anyway. Those emails are the strongest contemporaneous evidence that the decision to execute the warrant was contested inside the government that sought it.
The Current Inquiry
This month the Justice Department assigned Bill Essayli, a prosecutor from California, to work on a criminal investigation into the 2022 search and into Smith’s handling of the documents case. The assignment sits inside a larger probe in the Southern District of Florida that looks at whether former officials conspired to deprive Trump of his rights. Previous prosecutors on that broader effort have left. No charges have been filed. No court has issued a final ruling that the warrant itself was illegal. The only judicial determination that has stuck is the 2024 dismissal of the indictment on appointment grounds. Smith’s final report remains sealed by the same Florida judge who dismissed the case; she has blocked its release.
The assignment of the top federal prosecutor at Los Angeles to investigate whether the search of Mar-a-Lago mansion in 2022 was unlawful marks the seriousness with which the Department of Justice is intent on scrutinizing the probes of President Trump
https://t.co/aRpeitLpdt
— The New York Sun (@NewYorkSun) November 20, 2026
Where the Matter Stands
The criminal case against Trump is over. The appointment of the special counsel who brought it has been ruled unconstitutional by the judge who handled the matter. Internal FBI records show that agents raised probable-cause objections that were overruled. An investigation into the legality of the search is now active. Whether that investigation produces charges, or whether any higher court later reviews the warrant’s validity, remains open. The documents case itself never reached a jury. That is the record as of this week.
Help American Liberty PAC in our mission to elect conservatives and save our nation. Support – American Liberty PAC
