Talarico Came Back at a Concert. The Call Came From Ohio.

James Talarico was at the Austin City Limits festival on Friday, shaking hands and standing next to a country singer for a camera. That ended the disappearance. It did not end the argument about where he had been. On Sunday a recorded call to a mental-health hospital outside Cincinnati was posted, in which a woman who said she worked there indicated he had been discharged. His campaign called it a lie and said he was home in Austin with the flu. The hospital will not confirm a patient. Early voting starts in eight days. The question is no longer whether he was gone. It is which story a voter is asked to believe, and what either story does to a Senate race this late.

What is on the record

The last in-person campaign event in Texas before the gap was September 26 in Carrollton. He was in New York for a fundraiser around the 29th. On the 30th he appeared by video for a Hispanic business group in Edinburg, said he had been to urgent care in Dallas the night before, and said he had the flu, a fever, and was contagious. Then the events stopped. The president called him missing in action. Ken Paxton put up posters and opened a tip line. The campaign said flu, and said he would be back this weekend.

He was. Friday afternoon he was on the festival grounds in Austin. The campaign posted the video and said the conspiracy theorists would be disappointed, because he was alive and meeting voters. Paxton’s answer was that the flu had not stopped him from seeing New York donors, and that a music festival most working Texans cannot attend was a strange way to end two weeks off. He is booked for a Dallas fundraiser Sunday night and a televised town hall on October 14.

What the call claims, and what it is not

On Sunday Nick Sortor and Rhein Amacher posted audio of a call to the Lindner Center of Hope in Mason, Ohio, a facility that treats mental illness around the clock. A woman on the line, asked about Talarico, said something to the effect that he had just been discharged that evening, and that was why she did not have the record in front of her. She identified the place when asked. The posters called it confirmation that the flu was a lie.

It is not confirmation. The woman is not named. The facility’s representative, Jennifer Pierson, told a reporter the center does not disclose information about current or former patients, and would not. A hospital switchboard is not a records office, and a hospital that follows the privacy statute is not supposed to answer the question that was asked. There is chatter about a private plane from Austin to Hamilton, Ohio, on Thursday night and back Friday morning. That is chatter. It is not a flight log in the public file.

The campaign’s answer, from spokesman JT Ennis on Sunday afternoon, was flat. This is a lie designed to promote a pathetic conspiracy theory. Last week James Talarico was home in Austin, Texas, recovering from the flu. That is the official account. It contradicts the call. It does not explain a twelve-day hole with one video appearance at the front of it and a concert at the back.

What it means if the call is right

A candidate who spent part of the final month in a psychiatric hospital, and whose campaign told the state it was influenza, has two problems that do not cancel each other. The first is the illness. A breakdown under the pressure of a Senate race is a fact a voter is allowed to weigh. The job he wants does not get lighter after the oath. The second is the cover story. If the flu was a screen, the screen was a false statement from a campaign, repeated while the president and the opponent were asking where he was. Fitness is a fair question. Honesty about the fitness is the one that ends campaigns.

Stephen Miller has already said the candidate should release the medical records. That is the clean way out if the call is noise, and the hard way out if it is not. A man who was home in Austin with a fever can produce the urgent-care note and the calendar. A man who was in Mason cannot produce the note without producing the other thing. The town hall on the 14th will be watched for the answer as much as for the policy.

What it means if the campaign is right

If he was in Austin the whole time, the audio is a dirty trick that used a hospital’s phone line and a candidate’s name, and it still worked. It ate the weekend. It put the words mental hospital next to his name in every feed in Texas, three weeks from Election Day and eight days from the first ballot. Paxton does not have to prove the call. He has to repeat the absence, the skipped Hispanic business event, the skipped civic symposium, and the festival, and let the recording do the rest. A denial from a spokesman does not unring a hospital’s name.

Either way the absence already did its work. While Paxton was taking hits, Talarico handed him a week of “where is he” and then a weekend of “was it a hospital.” The flu story was thin on day three. It is thinner on day twelve, with a concert in the middle and an Ohio area code on the tape. The campaign says Austin. The tape says Mason. The voter gets the town hall, the early ballot, and a choice about which one he trusts. A Senate race does not pause for a medical chart. This one is being run on the question of whether the chart exists.

Help American Liberty PAC in our mission to elect conservatives and save our nation. Support – American Liberty PAC